Off-Market Properties in Middle Island
Distressed and long-held properties in Middle Island that never reach MLS. Owner intelligence and distress scoring from public records.
50
Distressed
83
Auction
1,031
Vacant parcels
Featured parcels
Sign up free to see owner names, exact arrears, and motivation scores for all 133+ matching parcels.
42 East Bartlett Road
Middle Island · Middle Island
10.08 ac·FMV —
Tax arrears detected
Nearby: Middle Island
BELLE TERRE AVE
Middle Island · Brookhaven
4.00 ac·FMV $104K
Tax arrears detected
Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
COUNTY ROAD 111
Middle Island · Brookhaven
9.75 ac·FMV $255K
Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
WHISKEY RD
Middle Island · Brookhaven
3.40 ac·FMV $438K
Tax arrears detected
Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
COUNTY ROAD 111
Middle Island · Brookhaven
23958 sqft·FMV $63K
Tax arrears detected
Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
Get the full report — free
See owner names, exact arrears amounts, filing dates, and motivation scores. 5 full parcel reports a month, free forever.
Primary-source data from ArcGIS, Suffolk County Clerk, and town tax portals