Middle Island, NY

Hamlet in Suffolk County · part of Brookhaven. Parcel-level information for Middle Island, NY — sourced from Suffolk County public records.

5,171
Parcels
1,018
Vacant
128
Distressed
83
Auction

Full property report on any Middle Island parcel — $49

Owner and mailing address, year-by-year tax arrears, recorded violations and distress signals, assessed value and last sale, plus zoning district, FEMA flood zone, permit history and buildability.

Pick a parcel

Delivered as a PDF. No account needed.

Auction properties

See all 83
35 Cove Dr
Sound Beach, NY
2024 Auction List
10019 sqft·FMV $38K
Appeared on county auction list
On 2024 auction list
Nearby: Brookhaven
Rosewood Rd
Rocky Point, NY
2024 Auction List
7841 sqft·FMV $33K
Appeared on county auction list
On 2024 auction list
Nearby: Brookhaven
Route 25A
Rocky Point, NY
2024 Auction List
17860 sqft·FMV $250K
Appeared on county auction list
On 2024 auction list
Nearby: Brookhaven
Toledo St
Miller Place, NY
2024 Auction List
13939 sqft·FMV $16K
Appeared on county auction list
On 2024 auction list
Nearby: Brookhaven
107 Sequoia Dr
Coram, NY
2024 Auction List
17860 sqft·FMV $625K
Appeared on county auction list
On 2024 auction list
Nearby: Brookhaven
11 Wildwood Rd
Ridge, NY
2024 Auction List
22216 sqft·FMV $521K
Appeared on county auction list
On 2024 auction list
Nearby: Brookhaven

Most distressed this month

See all 128
10 Jonah Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
1.20 ac·FMV $733K·Arrears 5+ years
Tax arrears detected
Absentee owner
Nearby: MILLER PLACE
4 Humming Ln
Middle Island, NY 11953
14810 sqft·FMV $591K·Arrears 5+ years
Tax arrears detected
Absentee owner
Nearby: CORAM
91 Whiskey Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
1.10 ac·FMV $772K·Arrears 2–4 years
Tax arrears detected
Nearby: MIDDLE ISLAND
48 Middle Island Blvd
Middle Island, NY 11953
1.15 ac·FMV $767K·Arrears 2–4 years
Tax arrears detected
Nearby: MIDDLE ISLAND
302 Swezeytown Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
25700 sqft·FMV $311K·Arrears 2–4 years
Tax arrears detected
Absentee owner
Nearby: MIDDLE ISLAND
58 Coram Swezeytwn Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
41382 sqft·FMV $256K·Arrears <2 years
Tax arrears detected
Estate / executor deed
Nearby: MIDDLE ISLAND

Recent parcels in Middle Island

Belle Terre Ave
Middle Island, NY 11953
4.00 ac·FMV $104K
Long-held owner (15+ yrs)Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
10 Jonah Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
1.20 ac·FMV $733K·Arrears 5+ years
Absentee owner
Nearby: MILLER PLACE
151 Whiskey Road
Middle Island, NY 11953
2.19 ac·FMV $0K
Long-held owner (15+ yrs)
Nearby: Middle Island
County Road 111
Middle Island, NY 11953
9.75 ac·FMV $255K
Long-held owner (15+ yrs)Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
Whiskey Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
3.40 ac·FMV $438K
Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
144 Whiskey Road
Middle Island, NY 11953
28183 sqft·FMV $2K
Long-held owner (15+ yrs)
Nearby: Middle Island
County Road 111
Middle Island, NY 11953
23958 sqft·FMV $63K
Long-held owner (15+ yrs)Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
County Road 111
Middle Island, NY 11953
20.35 ac·FMV $917K
Long-held owner (15+ yrs)Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven
County Road 111
Middle Island, NY 11953
7.59 ac·FMV $156K
Absentee owner
Nearby: Brookhaven

See all 128 distressed homes in Middle Island

Owner names, exact arrears amounts, filing dates, and motivation scores. 5 full parcel reports a month, free forever.

No password. We email you a one-click sign-in link. We also send the weekly distress digest — unsubscribe in one click.

No password. No credit card. Magic link arrives in 30 seconds.

Built on Suffolk County, NY public records

ParcelIntel is the real-estate investment intelligence platform built specifically for Suffolk County investors, builders, and flippers.

Popular searches in Middle Island

Land for Sale in Middle IslandDistressed Properties in Middle IslandTax Auction Properties in Middle IslandVacant Land in Middle IslandTax Delinquent Homes in Middle IslandForeclosures in Middle IslandShort Sale Homes in Middle IslandOff-Market Properties in Middle IslandForeclosed Homes in Middle IslandMiddle Island Property Records